Do You Really Need hang on back vs canister? Pros & Cons

Do You Really Need Hang on Back vs Canister? Pros & Cons

If you’re building your dream aquascape, choosing the right filter is a make-or-break decision for water clarity, plant health, and the success of your aquatic life. But the burning question remains: Do you really need a hang on back (HOB) filter, a canister filter, or something else entirely? In this comprehensive guide, we’ll dive deep into the pros and cons of hang on back vs canister filters in aquascaping so you can pick the best filter for your aquarium setup.

What Are Hang on Back (HOB) and Canister Filters?

Before comparing, let’s define the core differences between these popular aquarium filters:

Hang on Back (HOB) Filters: Compact devices that hang on the rim of your aquarium, drawing water up from the tank, passing it through filter media, and returning it in a simple waterfall or stream back into the tank.
Canister Filters: External filter units placed beside or below the aquarium. Water leaves the tank via intake tubes, passes through multi-stage filtration inside the canister, and returns via an output tube.

Both types are commonly used in freshwater planted aquariums, but they have unique strengths and weaknesses for aquascaping enthusiasts.

Hang on Back vs Canister: Pros & Cons for Aquascaping

Pros of Hang On Back (HOB) Filters

Easy Installation and Maintenance: HOB filters are known for their plug-and-play simplicity. They’re ideal for beginners or anyone who wants a no-fuss system.
Affordability: Typically, HOB filters cost much less than canister filters, making them a solid option for budget-conscious aquascapers.
Space Saving: They don’t require additional cabinet or floor space, which is great for small setups or desks.
Quick Access: Changing filter media and cleaning the unit is simple, requiring little time or disassembly.
Oxygenation: The water return creates surface agitation, helping to oxygenate your aquascape.

Cons of Hang On Back (HOB) Filters

Limited Filtration Volume: Suitable for small to medium tanks (typically up to 55 gallons). Larger aquascapes may overwhelm the filter’s capacity.
Visible Equipment: The filter hangs on the back, partially visible inside and above the tank—and the intake tube can disrupt your aquascape’s aesthetics.
Flow Control: Some HOBs have fixed flow rates, which can create dead spots or blow plants around if not positioned carefully.
Media Customization: Less flexibility compared to canister filters in choosing or layering filter media for customized water parameters.

Pros of Canister Filters

Powerful, Multi-Stage Filtration: Canister filters excel at mechanical, chemical, and biological filtration, supporting large or heavily-stocked aquascapes.
Customizable Filter Media: Arrange sponges, bio-media, and specialty resins in a way that suits your planted aquarium’s unique needs.
Discreet Placement: Canister filters are hidden below or beside the tank, with only the intake/output tubes visible—great for minimalist or nature aquarium designs.
Better Flow Control: Many canisters let you adjust flow direction and intensity, ideal for even circulation in a densely planted tank.
Supports CO₂ Injection: Less surface agitation means less loss of CO₂, essential for advanced aquascaping and lush plant growth.

Cons of Canister Filters

Higher Cost: Expect to pay more upfront for the unit and possibly replacement parts.
Complex Setup: Initial installation is more involved, including priming, hose routing, and regular disassembly for cleaning.
Takes Up Space: These filters require a cabinet or nearby floor space, which isn’t ideal for compact displays.
Maintenance Effort: Cleaning can be messier and more time-consuming compared to HOB filters.

Which Filter Should You Choose for Your Aquascape?

The right answer depends on your aquarium size, inhabitants, plant load, and personal preferences. Here’s a quick guide:

For nano and small aquascapes (30 gallons or less): HOB filters are practical and budget-friendly. They easily handle low to moderate bioloads and take little visual space.
For medium to large tanks (40 gallons or more): Canister filters provide the necessary filtration power, water clarity, and minimal equipment visibility needed for thriving, show-stopping layouts.
For aquascapes with demanding plant species or CO₂ injection: Canisters reduce surface agitation, keeping essential CO₂ dissolved for vibrant growth.
For beginners or quick setups: HOBs are easy to install and maintain, perfect for first-time aquascapers.

Also consider the right filter media for aquascaping to further enhance water quality regardless of your chosen filter style.

Additional Factors to Consider

Filtration Noise: HOB filters may be slightly louder due to cascading water, while canisters usually run quieter but may produce hum from the motor.
Aquascape Style: Consider visibility and visual clutter. For Iwagumi or nature aquarium aquascapes, minimizing equipment distracts less from your aquascape design.
Budget vs. Performance: Balance your desire for low maintenance and aesthetic appeal with your available budget and the needs of your fish and plants.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I use both a hang on back and canister filter together?

Yes, combining filters can provide redundancy and improved water quality, but it may be overkill for most hobbyists. Focus on optimizing one filter first.

Are there other filter options for planted tanks?

Absolutely! Sponge filters are ideal for shrimp tanks or breeding setups, while internal power filters and sumps have their place in specialized aquascapes.

How often should I clean my aquarium filter?

Every 2–4 weeks is standard, but observe your filter’s flow and water clarity. Always rinse filter media with tank water to protect beneficial bacteria.

Conclusion: Making Your Filter Choice

When it comes to hang on back vs canister filters for aquascaping, there’s no one-size-fits-all answer. HOB filters shine in small systems and for beginners, while canister filters deliver powerful, customizable filtration for larger, advanced setups. Evaluate your tank’s needs, aquascaping goals, and budget to make the best decision for healthy aquatic life and lush, thriving plants.

Looking for more expert aquascaping advice? Check out our Aquascaping Basics or Best Plants for Beginners to further enhance your underwater masterpiece.

Ready to level up your aquascape? Subscribe to the Aquascaping Academy newsletter for the latest guides, tips, and inspiration straight to your inbox!